Participation and Performance: Why School Sport Needs Both

Participation and Performance: Why School Sport Needs Both

Participation and Performance: Why School Sport Needs Both

Everyone loves to win, let's get that out of the way first!

Winning is fun, and it always will be. There is something deeply satisfying about seeing effort rewarded, pressure managed, skills executed and goals achieved. Trophies, medals and championships matter because they represent something meaningful: the visible result of weeks, months or years of dedication. Winning can also mean taking the next step, accessing a higher level of competition and opening new opportunities.

In independent school sport, we often find ourselves caught in debates about how to balance participation with performance. Should we prioritise opportunities for all, or competitive success? Should resources go towards participation programmes or performance pathways? Should we celebrate the first-team player or the pupil attending a sports club for the very first time?

The truth is that these conversations can make it sound as if we have to choose a side. We don't. Participation and performance are complementary parts of a successful sporting programme. Each deserves attention and investment, and each contributes to the wider educational purpose of school sport.

Sport should help young people fulfil their potential. The interesting part is that potential looks very different depending on who is standing in front of you. For one pupil, it may mean representing their country. For another, it may be finding the confidence to join a lunchtime club. For one, success is standing on a podium; for another, it is discovering a form of exercise they still enjoy twenty years after leaving school. Every one of those young people deserves our attention. Which is where things become complicated.

Sport England's 2015 report, Under the Skin: Understanding Youth Personalities, explored the lives and sporting attitudes of 1,997 young people aged 14 to 25. It described six broad groups shaped by motivations, attitudes and engagement with sport. Sport England was clear that these categories are broad and can overlap. For schools, the useful lesson is to ask what matters to each young person and recognise that their motivations can change over time. These can include competition, friendship, enjoyment, belonging, confidence or wellbeing. Some actively seek challenge. Others may first need an environment where they feel comfortable taking part.

When you look across the halls, gyms, pitches and courts, it can be tempting to see simply a group of pupils. In reality, you are looking at different motivations, worries, ambitions and aspirations. So why do so many sports programmes still offer essentially the same experience to everybody? Why would we expect a highly competitive athlete and a cautious beginner to be motivated by the same messages? And why do we sometimes measure success using metrics that matter most to only a small proportion of participants? These are uncomfortable questions, but they matter.

Schools should celebrate sporting excellence. At the same time, most young people will not become elite athletes, and all will leave school needing to understand how physical activity can contribute to their health, wellbeing and quality of life. If we genuinely care about lifelong participation, perhaps a better question is this:

Are we preparing young people to win the next match, or to be active for the next fifty years?

High performance belongs within this wider purpose. Ambitious pathways matter, and pupils who want to reach the highest level deserve support to do so. Evidence on goal setting in sport shows that process goals can support performance alongside ambitious outcomes. A 2024 systematic review and meta-analysis by Williamson et al., The performance and psychological effects of goal setting in sport, published in the International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, examined 27 studies. It found that process goals had the largest average effect on performance among the goal types reviewed, and a positive effect on self-efficacy in the studies that measured it. These are average findings from the included studies, so they offer useful guidance without predicting the result for every athlete. They support using process goals alongside performance and outcome goals.

Yet many adults still ask the same question after a fixture: 'Did you win?' More useful questions might be: 'What did you learn?', 'What were you trying to improve today?' or 'What are you proud of?' The language we use, the behaviours we reward and the experiences we create all influence how young people understand sporting success. If the scoreboard is consistently our main measure, we should not be surprised when pupils see it the same way.

One way to put this into practice is to agree what success looks like before each fixture in our sporting programme. We might set an outcome goal, such as finishing in the top two to qualify for regionals. A performance goal might be improving on a personal best. A process goal focuses on specific actions, skills or tactics that pupils can control. The emphasis can change from fixture to fixture, and the goals can work together: an outcome gives direction, a performance goal helps us track progress, and a process goal guides what we do. Sometimes we are absolutely focused on the outcome. Often, the most useful focus is on process or performance.

Perhaps that is the biggest challenge to conventional thinking: success can be measured by more than the scoreboard. Society has often presented participation and performance as competing priorities. One is associated with inclusion and accessibility; the other with ambition and competitive excellence. Yet the best sporting environments rarely operate at either extreme.

The athlete chasing international success still needs enjoyment. The nervous beginner still benefits from challenge. Both need confidence, belonging and opportunities to experience success. A well-designed programme can offer the stretch that helps committed athletes improve and the welcome that helps a less confident pupil take a first step.

For Directors of Sport across PADSIS, this is a leadership responsibility. We need to look beyond traditional measures and ask whether our programmes reflect the different motivations, abilities and aspirations of the young people in our care. We need to provide enough opportunity for those who want to compete at the highest level, while also creating environments where pupils who are less confident, less experienced or simply motivated by enjoyment can thrive.

Perhaps the real measure of a sporting programme is not whether everybody wins, because that is impossible. Nor is it simply whether everybody participates, because genuine participation requires choice, motivation and enjoyment. Perhaps the better measure is whether every young person can find a place where they can grow.

For Directors of Sport, that leaves three useful questions:

1.  Does our sporting programme offer meaningful opportunities for pupils with different motivations, abilities and aspirations?

2.  Are we measuring success through participation, personal development and improvement, as well as competitive results?

3.  Are we creating a sporting culture in which excellence is celebrated without making participation feel exclusive?

That means maintaining ambitious performance pathways and enabling pupils to fulfil their potential, while continuing to broaden participation opportunities. We must consider both what is offered and how it is offered.

It means celebrating representative honours while recognising the pupil who attends a club for the first time. It means pursuing excellence without allowing excellence to become exclusive. It means understanding that performance and participation are not opposite ends of a spectrum, but partners in the same mission.

After all, the most successful sporting cultures are not those that produce the most winners. They are the ones that produce the most people who still want to be active long after the final whistle has blown.